I wonder if it is being suggested that, because icey's relative used photgraphs of her for inappropriate purposes, my uncle should be on the Sex Offenders Register too.

... and my parents for permitting him to take pictures of my naked sister?

... and me, for keeping the photographs?

Yet not one of us has used the pictures for sexual stimulation or arousal - simply to record an amusing event.

Is it art? Yes, of a kind, although only a very low level of skill was required to take the pictures. The result is a pictoral story of a child's consternation as her bathwater disappears. But if that is not enough, then I would add that it also serves as a historical document of a well-remembered family event.

Isn't the solution to punish the offender, not everyone else?